We’ve Got the Homemade Butterfinger Balls Ideas That Your Family Will Love!

Christmas is around the corner, and that means it’s time to start getting creative with your baking! The best Butterfinger balls recipe is the perfect way to make delicious and easy Butterfinger balls for beginners for all of your friends and family. This simple Butterfinger balls meal is easy to make and absolutely delicious. We think that you’re going to love them!

Making Butterfinger Balls is a tradition for so many families. The Holidays are the time when these are enjoyed more. These are so easy to make and they are addicting. They are the perfect treat for any occasion.

Their rich flavor just melts off the tongue, and their texture is both creamy and crispy. To us, that makes them dang near the perfect dish for the holidays! After all, everybody is looking to chow down on amazing treats.

Making family friendly Butterfinger balls is a tradition for so many people around the world. In fact, the holidays are typically the time when this quick Butterfinger balls recipe is enjoyed more often. These family friendly Butterfinger balls are so easy to make and are addictive, which makes them the perfect treat for any occasion.

Looking for homemade Butterfinger balls ideas that taste just like the candy bar and will be loved by everyone? We can help you! In fact, we can even create a healthy Butterfinger balls version you’ll enjoy, so be sure to try them out for yourself and let us know what you think!

Scroll to bottom for printable recipe card.

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

• The best Butterfinger balls recipe is super easy – all you are doing is taking one of your favorite candy bars, crushing it, and turning it into an all-new treat
• Our easy Butterfinger balls for beginners are amazingly tasty – these are so addicting, you will be left speechless 
• You can try many homemade Butterfinger balls ideas for your simple Butterfinger balls meal – try milk chocolate, almond bark, or even chocolate chips
• This is a quick Butterfinger balls recipe – this recipe takes about 45 minutes to complete 
• You get a lot of bang for your buck with these family friendly Butterfinger balls – you get about  two dozen Butterfinger balls
• Making a healthy Butterfinger balls version is tricky but not impossible – we’ll teach you how!

Ingredient Notes & Substitutions

• Graham Cracker Crumbs: The best Butterfinger balls recipe uses a little graham cracker to make a nice crust for your snack. Want a healthier, easy Butterfinger balls for beginners? Use homemade oat flour or almond flour crackers instead.
• Bitesize Butterfinger Candy Bars: Your simple Butterfinger balls meal centers surround these, but do we have any healthier homemade Butterfinger balls ideas? Well, you can emulate this candy bar with peanut butter, honey, and gluten-free cornflakes.
• Creamy Peanut Butter: Your quick Butterfinger balls recipe needs peanut butter to add more texture and flavor to your treat. A healthy Butterfinger balls version foregoes this ingredient and uses almond or sunflower seed oil instead.
• Ghiradelli Dark Chocolate Melting Wafers: These decadent wafers make truly family friendly Butterfinger balls that kids will love. Healthier alternatives include carob and cocoa powder, but it’s hard to imagine this snack without these wafers.

How to Make It

The best Butterfinger balls recipe isn’t too hard. In fact, there are only a handful of steps. Start by adding powdered sugar, graham cracker crumbs, Butterfinger bits, melted butter, and creamy peanut butter to a large bowl. That’s almost half of your simple Butterfinger balls meal there!

Blend everything together with an electric mixer. Make sure that everything is evenly blended, or your quick Butterfinger balls recipe won’t be as successful. Of all the homemade Butterfinger balls ideas possible, skimping on this step is the worst one of all. 

Next step when making easy Butterfinger balls for beginners is to use a #60 cookie scoop to make the balls. You want that size because it creates consistent, solid, and thick balls. Once you’ve scooped a bunch out, line a baking sheet with parchment paper and put them on it.

You know what’s awesome? You don’t need to cook your family friendly Butterfinger balls right now! Instead, chill them for 30 minutes. While they’re sitting, you’ll handle the next step to save a little on prep time. 

Melt your wafers following the melting directions on the back of the package. Now, you can remove the chilled balls from the refrigerator. Set them down somewhere with plenty of light so you can complete the next steps properly. 

Here’s the fun part! Wash your hands, get the kids in the room, dip the balls into the melted chocolate, and sprinkle the crushed Butterfinger candy bar pieces on the freshly dipped balls. You’re definitely going to get messy: have fun with it!

After chilling the balls in the fridge for another few minutes, add the melted chocolate to a piping bag with a small round tip and cover the Butterfinger balls with the chocolate and the candy bar bits. They’re going to look really good right about now, so dig in and enjoy!

Tips For Success

• Simplify these easy Butterfinger balls for beginners by using homemade Butterfinger balls ideas like using pre-crushed candy to streamline the process
• Don’t be afraid to make a lot with this best Butterfinger balls recipe – people will basically be asking you for them for years
• Keep crushed candy bars around to make speed up an already quick Butterfinger balls recipe – they’re also useful for cakes and other treats
• Make sure to put your simple Butterfinger balls meal in the fridge – the balls need to be cold in order for the chocolate to stick.
• Try using all-natural peanut butter to make a slight change in these – they may not end up as crispy, but they’re a healthy Butterfinger balls version you may like, too
• Mix other candy bars in to make family friendly Butterfinger balls that everyone in your family may enjoy

Storage & Reheating

These only need to be put into the refrigerator and can be kept in an airtight container for up to one week. These Butterfinger balls can also be frozen for up to three months. Unthaw by leaving them in the fridge overnight.

Serving Suggestions

• Serve chilled on a simple plate for great results
• Coffee and milk pair wonderfully with these
• During the holiday season, some sprinkles make them even better
• Drizzled chocolate adds a little more flair to this treat
• Moist toilette wipes keep your hands clean with this snack
• These pair well with chocolate bundt cake

Notes

Next to my chocolate eclairs, this treat gets the most traction around Christmastime. My kids and partner are obsessed with them, which is why it’s great they’re so easy to make! The first time I stumbled onto this recipe, I could hardly believe it. I tried them out a few times because it seemed so amazing that they were this basic but so good. Now, they’re an absolute staple in my home!

THANKS FOR PINING!