Amish Potato Salad

Amish Potato Salad {Sweet Pea's Kitchen}

Summer barbecues and picnics just aren’t the same without a large helping of potato salad. There’s just something about it that screams summertime to me. I can honestly say that I’ve never made potato salad from scratch before, so when I went looking for a recipe to try I couldn’t believe all of the different combinations! There were potato salads with a mayonnaise base, mustard base, even a vinegar base. They’re were even ones with bacon, anchovies, or tomatoes mixed in! I ultimately decided on my favorite style-Amish Potato Salad.

Amish Potato Salad {Sweet Pea's Kitchen}

The secret to a perfect potato salad is to use firm-textured Yukon Gold potatoes. They hold their shape after cooking and won’t turn mushy in the salad. It’s also very important to gently simmer the potatoes and not to overcook them, if the tip of a paring knife inserts easily into the potato pieces, they’re done.

Amish Potato Salad {Sweet Pea's Kitchen}

Drizzling the hot potatoes with a few tablespoons of dressing helps the potatoes soak up more of the rich flavor and isn’t a step that should be overlooked. Trust me on this one, you want every bite to be perfectly seasoned to perfection.

Amish Potato Salad

Creamy, Amish-style potato salad made with cider vinegar, eggs, mustard, sour cream and celery.

Yield: Serves 8


3 pounds Yukon Gold potatoes, peeled and cut into 3/4-inch chunks
Salt and pepper
1/3 cup cider vinegar
1/4 cup sugar
2 tablespoons yellow mustard
4 large hard-cooked eggs, peeled
1/2 teaspoon celery seed
3/4 cup sour cream
1 celery rib, chopped fine


1. In a large pot over high heat bring potatoes, 1 tablespoon salt, and enough water to cover by 1 inch to a boil. Reduce heat to medium and simmer until potatoes are just tender, about 10 minutes.

2. While potatoes simmer, microwave vinegar and sugar in small bowl until sugar dissolves, about 30 seconds. Process vinegar mixture, mustard, 1 hard-cooked egg yolk (reserve white), celery seed, and ½ teaspoon salt in food processor until smooth. Transfer to medium bowl, reserving 2 tablespoons for drizzling; set aside.

3. Drain potatoes thoroughly, then transfer to large bowl. Drizzle reserved 2 tablespoons of dressing over hot potatoes and, using rubber spatula, gently toss until evenly coated. Refrigerate until cooled, at least 30 minutes.

4. Whisk sour cream into remaining dressing. Add remaining hard-cooked eggs and egg white to dressing and, using potato masher, mash until only small pieces remain. Add dressing and celery to cooled potatoes. Cover and refrigerate until chilled, about 30 -minutes. Season with salt and pepper. Serve.

Recipe Notes:
You can substitute an equal amount of celery salt for the celery seed. If you do, omit the salt from the dressing.
For best flavor, make 12 to 24 hours before you plan on serving.

Source: Cook's Country, June/July 2010

One Year Ago: Nutella Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookies Nutella Stuffed Chocolate Chip Cookies {Sweet Pea's Kitchen}

Two Years AgoMargarita Lime Cookies Margarita Lime Cookies

Three Years Ago: Cocoa Brownies with Browned Butter and Walnuts Cocoa Brownies with Browned Butter and Walnuts

6 Responses to “Amish Potato Salad”

  1. #
    Annie McPhee — May 26, 2014 @ 3:15 pm

    This looks great, and given that I hate mayonnaise definitely something that I will try. But, reading your instructions made me laugh.

    As far as I know, the Amish don’t have microwaves!!! I think when I saw the name of the recipe I was expecting low tech cooking methods to go with the simple ingredients. Be that as it may, I will give this one a try. 🙂

  2. #
    Liz — May 26, 2014 @ 5:29 pm

    Nice potato salad. Thank you and have a Great Week

  3. #
    Robin @ Simply Southern Baking — May 27, 2014 @ 6:37 am

    Now this is my kind of potato salad since I’m not a mayo fan. Looks delish!

  4. #
    Lisa Combs — May 27, 2014 @ 10:49 am

    I make this same recipe, except I reduced the vinegar and sugar amts by half…my family loves it…..

  5. #
    Beth R. — May 27, 2014 @ 1:35 pm

    Im from PA and have been eating potato salad very close to this recipe all my life. I would add onions and leave out the sour cream and mustard, especially the mustard. With the vinegar and sugar making a sweet and sour dressing, you dont need the mustard too, try it.

  6. #
    kevin williams — May 27, 2014 @ 10:16 pm

    The formulation of the recipe looks midwestern, traditional Amish…I’m sure the instructions were tweaked for a modern kitchen, that is something I do all the time on my website, otherwise you’d have impractical instructions for everyday cooks…it looks like a great recipe!

Leave a Comment