The Best Buttered Pecan Cookies for Your Home: Teachers Will Love Them!

When Christmas time comes around, I begin making my list of all the goodies that I plan to make for the Holidays. I came up with these best buttered pecan cookies ideas a few years ago, and they are always at the top of my list. Of course, I make these throughout the year because this easy buttered pecan cookies recipe is such a joy to make!

Put simply, I love the flavor of these simple buttered pecan cookies dessert, and I love how easy these homemade buttered pecan cookies recipes are to make. These are usually the first ones that are gone from the trays when I have parties or friends over. Most of my friends keep wanting to know how to make these quick buttered pecan cookies for parties of their own!

As one of the most popular Christmas Traditions, these family favorite buttered pecan cookies make people happy. The cookies are sweet and nutty and of course, butter-flavored. If you’re interested in baking buttered pecan cookies at home, they’re very easy!

There are only basic ingredients needed for this recipe. So what are you waiting for? Get baking!

Don’t forget to check out other recipes here, including our pecan praline! I will bust that out from time to time, and it never fails to impress everyone!

Scroll to bottom for printable recipe card.

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

• The easy buttered pecan cookies recipe is simple, and the cookies are easy to make – expertise not required 
• Great homemade buttered pecan cookies recipes always taste better than store cookies
• The best buttered pecan cookies ideas can be easily adapted to new, great ideas
• These simple buttered pecan cookies dessert come out chewy and gooey
• Making these quick buttered pecan cookies for parties requires only Basic ingredients.
• Family favorite buttered pecan cookies are great all year round.
• You can try baking buttered pecan cookies at home a day in advanceEasy to adapt into things like pecan bars if you want

Ingredient Notes & Substitutions

• Eggs: You’ll need eggs to make cookies, though you might get around that by using egg replacement powders. Some people even like aquafaba or the liquid from canned chickpeas, when making the best buttered pecan cookies ideas.
• Pecans: Your easy buttered pecan cookies recipe calls for full pecans for the cookies and pecan halves for the tops. Thankfully, you can adapt your homemade buttered pecan cookies recipes by adding almonds or walnuts, if you prefer
• Brown Sugar: Brown sugar gives your simple buttered pecan cookies dessert a nice, darker sweetness. The finest quick buttered pecan cookies for parties can also use white sugar mixed with molasses if you don’t have brown sugar around.
• Vanilla: Our family favorite buttered pecan cookies use vanilla to add a touch of light flavor to these cookies. Maple syrup, honey, and almond extract also work, but I tend to find that vanilla provides the best mix.

How to Make It

While you wait for your oven to hit 350 degrees, you can blend the butter, granulated sugar, and brown sugar in a bowl until creamy. You want to use a whisk when making this easy buttered pecan cookies recipe to ensure it blends properly.

At this point, you can add the vanilla extract and eggs to the mixing bowl and blend until smooth. Try out some fun best buttered pecan cookies ideas as you go, such as getting your kids to join in the mixing or adding various types of flavors.

At this point, your homemade buttered pecan cookies recipes need you to mix in the baking soda, flour, and salt to produce a consistent dough. Put in the whole pecans now and mix them throughout the dough. A good spread should include 2-3 pecans per inch or so.

Mixing is always fun

Starting to look good

Put some flour on a baking area and on your hands (after washing them), and start folding your cookies. You and your kids should be able to get 24 one-inch balls out of this dough. Kids really love this step when making quick buttered pecan cookies for parties because they like getting their hands dirty.

Now, put your simple buttered pecan cookies dessert on a parchment-lined baking sheet and top each with a pecan half. If you want to be cute, you can even make little half-pecan “tents” by leaning the halves together.

Slide your family favorite buttered pecan cookies into the fully warmed oven. After 10-15 minutes, you can take them out. Baking buttered pecan cookies at home like this is a fun activity that you and your kids will enjoy!

Allow the cookies to cool before serving.

Now ready to serve!

Tips for Success

• While most cookie recipes will turn out better when the dough has been chilled prior to baking, this easy buttered pecan cookies recipe doesn’t need to be chilled prior to baking
• Add in dried fruit pieces, chocolate chips, nuts, or other best buttered pecan cookies ideas that will customize the cookie to your liking
• Check your pecans for any imperfections before cooking – only buy the freshest types to improve your homemade buttered pecan cookies recipes
• Let your dough sit for a bit before baking (around 10 minutes) to help it settle a little

Storage & Reheating

When your simple buttered pecan cookies dessert snacks have cooled to room temperature, you can place them into an airtight container for fridge storage. These family favorite buttered pecan cookies can be stored with waxed paper between the cookies in a cool and dry place.

After baking buttered pecan cookies at home, you can even freeze them. Cool them entirely and lay them between layers of wax paper in an airtight container. These quick buttered pecan cookies for parties can be stored for up to three months in the freezer.

Serving Suggestions

• Pair your cookies with a glass of milk or coffee as a light snack
• Ice cream goes perfectly with your cookies (vanilla in particular)
• Serve them right out of the oven for delicious gooey textures
• Pass a plate of pecan cookies out during the holidays
• Store them in a glass container with a piece of bread to preserve softness

Notes

I remember the first time I made these with my partner. It was our first date! They’d never done any baking before, but loved pecans. So, I came up with this recipe and we bonded over it. In fact, every time we make them even today, I remember that day we baked them together. That’s a beautiful memory, and it’s one I hope that you can make while cooking these tasty desserts.

THANKS FOR PINING!

More Cookies Recipes Ideas:

Thumbprint Cookies – Pretty yummy!!

Homemade Tagalongs Cookies – Every bite is filled with crunchy cookies, creamy peanut butter, and lots of chocolate.

Cool Whip Cookies – They were gone in a matter of minutes!