Italian Meatloaf

I did not like meatloaf as a kid. It was the worst. It was dry. It was boring. There wasn’t anything to do with it but to add ketchup to it. That’s probably why I didn’t really make it for my kids when they were younger. Then, I got creative. This Italian Meatloaf is nothing close to boring.

You can do this. I’m confident. You’ll see why it’s worth a few extra steps. Use good ingredients. Make sure they are high quality. Make sure you get the seasonings balanced. And adjust to fit your taste buds. Don’t forget all of the extra cheese on top. That’s not where you want to skimp on this recipe or calories.

When I first made this up, I thought my family would think I was trying some TikTok trend. What they learned was that they could eat ground beef with more than just burgers. You’ll see that it only takes a few minutes to make, but it changes the game on meatloaf. This is nothing like what I grew up eating. That’s good. I encourage you to give it a try. Even if you’re not confident, everyone will enjoy it. They will.

Scroll to bottom for printable recipe card.

Why I Love Italian Meatloaf

I love this easy Italian meatloaf recipe because it’s very flavorful, easy to make, and it goes well with a number of different side dishes that really complement this meatloaf. I also love the way everything stays so moist. That was a huge factor for me when I was younger. Dry and boring. Just don’t overcook it and you’ll see it’s almost as tender as a nice steak.

I love this recipe because it’s not greasy. For many people, that is a big issue. Dry or super greasy. Even with all of the cheese, you don’t feel it. It certainly seems like it’s over the top in terms of cheese. It’s luxurious, almost, when it comes to that extra gooeyness. But in reality, I love the way everything balances. My best tip? Save some for a sandwich for the next day!

Ingredients:

• Ground beef 80/20
• Ground mild Italian sausage
• Yellow onion
• Bell pepper
• Olive oil
• Worcestershire sauce
• Minced garlic
• Oregano
• Basil
• Parsley
• Eggs
• Italian bread crumbs
• Panko
• Milk
• Shredded mozzarella cheese
• Shredded mozzarella
• Parmesan cheese

Ingredient Deep Dive

Ground Beef

Traditionally, ground beef is the go-to in this recipe. It has a fuller flavor. It’s hearty. But you can make it with ground turkey. If you have an option, choose dark turkey meat. 

If not, consider mixing it with beef. However, whatever you do is up to you. It depends on your preference, and if you want a leaner meat, go with the turkey. However, the beef tends to have a better flavor.

Ground Mild Italian Sausage

Could you skip it? Yes. Should you? No way! That’s what brings all of the interesting flavor and texture. That is one of the reasons it is Italian meatloaf. 

The seasoning and flavors help to bring this together. You could choose another type of sausage or go with a hot version instead of mild. You could change up the Italian theme by choosing a Polish sausage. I haven’t done that yet, but it could be good!

Worcestershire Sauce

It’s amazing the depth of flavor this one ingredient brings to the meatloaf. I find there’s no simple substitute. This is something that can be used in so many other recipes and is such a flavor enhancer. 

It provides just the right twist to the meal. If you don’t have it, but you have soy sauce, you could make that switch. Just don’t skip it. You want the organic flavor this component offers.

How to make Italian Meatloaf:

Use a small skillet to fry up the veggies. Add in the olive oil first. Then, toss in the diced onion and bell pepper. I also like to add in the garlic now. Allow all of this to come together. The secret with Italian sauces is that it starts here. With a deep flavor profile. Sauté for at least four minutes. Make sure the onions are translucent. Then, turn it off and move it to the side.

Step 2: Build the Ground Beef Mixture

Use a large mixing bowl for this. Add in the beef and sausage. Mix it well. Then add in the onion mixture and seasonings. Make sure the seasonings are to your preference. Make this your personal dish. Once that’s incorporated, it’s time to add the eggs, milk, and cheese. I also mix the bread crumbs and panko together before mixing those in. Finally, do the entire thing with Worcestershire sauce.

Step 3: Mix and Mold

Mix to combine using your hands. Nothing else really works. Then, spray your loaf pan with a non-stick cooking spray. I sometimes line the very bottom of the pan with parchment. That way, I get an even top that looks good. Place the meatloaf mixture into the loaf pan. I like to hit the table a couple of times to make sure it all settles into place. Evenly distribute it across the pan.

Step 4: Bake It

It’s going to take some time. Most of the time, you’ll need to cook it at 400 degrees for at least 50 minutes. Don’t be tempted to turn the oven higher. That’s going to lead to drying out the meat on the exterior. It could be raw inside. Be patient when cooking this and make sure the oven is to temp before putting it in. This will help to ensure it is cooked evenly.

Step 5: Add the Cheese

Once it’s come to the proper temperature, remove it from the oven. Top with the remaining cheese and sprinkle a little dry basil over the top. Return to the oven for 10 more minutes. That’s going to melt the cheese well. Remove it from the oven and let it sit. Don’t try to cut into it for at least 10 minutes. Let the juices distribute back to where they were. This is super important.

After adding the cheese and returning to the oven.

SAVE this recipe on Pinterest for later 🙂

Pro-Tips and Techniques

Be sure to follow the recipe precisely for the best results, especially if you’re new to the world of cooking. If you’re an experienced cook, then you are knowledgeable about some small tweaks you can make without compromising the outcome of the recipe.

There is an unlimited number of ways to vary your Italian meatloaf, and the good thing is that meatloaf isn’t a dish that can be negatively affected by too many customizations. So, if you want to add some ingredients to your meatloaf or you’re interested in making substitutions, it can be easily done.

Serving and Pairings

There is no wrong way to serve Italian meatloaf. Whether you want to serve it with your favorite pasta noodles and broccoli, mashed potatoes and Brussels sprouts, or something else totally different, they are all wonderful ways to serve this dish. Try it with roasted garlic mashed potatoes or garlic cheese bread on the side.

FAQs and Troubleshooting

What is the Secret to Moist Meatloaf?

No one likes dry, hard meatloaf, and the key to moist meatloaf is to use high-fat meat, as lean meat will result in a drier meatloaf that is less desirable.

What Ingredient Keeps Meatloaf from Falling Apart?

Eggs and some type of bread can be used as binders to help hold your meatloaf together. Some people use croutons or bread crumbs, while other people use crushed-up bread or even oatmeal.

Why Do You Put Milk in Meatloaf?

Bread crumbs can make your meatloaf dry by reducing some of the necessary moisture, but milk adds back some of the lost moisture, which can help you bake a perfectly moist meatloaf.

How to Store Italian Meatloaf?

You should store Italian meatloaf as you would any leftovers in an airtight container to prevent air from reaching it and accelerating the growth of bacteria. An airtight container also helps your leftover Italian meatloaf to retain its flavor, because that is a common problem with leftovers, a loss of flavor after being refrigerated and then reheated.

How to Reheat Italian Meatloaf?

The key to perfectly reheated meatloaf is doing so at a low temperature, in order to retain the moisture. You should add a tablespoon or two of beef broth to the meatloaf before placing it in the oven for 25 minutes at 250 F. Your meatloaf should turn out as flavorful and as moist as it was initially.

How Long Does Italian Meatloaf Last in the Fridge?

If you store the leftover Italian meatloaf in an airtight container, you can expect it to stay fresh for as long as four days. After that, you need to place it in the freezer, where it could stay fresh for up to three months.

Can I Make Italian Meatloaf in Advance?

Yes, you can most definitely make this Italian meatloaf recipe ahead of time if you can’t make it the same day you’ll be serving it. In fact, this can be easily refrigerated or even frozen ahead of time until you’re ready to bake and serve it.

Related Recipes you Might Enjoy:

Since you’re going to be making this meatloaf, you will likely need some sides to accompany it. Here are some that you might like: 

Homemade Roasted Garlic Mashed Potatoes – everyone loves mashed potatoes with their meatloaf, and this mashed potato recipe will go well with it. 

Banana Split Pudding – this is a dessert that you might want to serve after enjoying your wonderful meatloaf meal. 

Oven Roasted Potatoes – this is an alternative to mashed potatoes that would also go well with Italian meatloaf.