The Best Big Boy’s Fresh Strawberry Pie Ideas: What’s More American?

Is there anything more tempting than freshly baked pie? We don’t think so, which is why we found the best Big Boys fresh strawberry pie ideas; they’re sure to satisfy any sweet tooth! With a rich flavor and creamy interior, this easy Big Boys fresh strawberry pie recipe will get you smiling.

Thankfully, our homemade Big Boys fresh strawberry pie recipes are simple to follow and create an end result with a truly delicious flavor. Anybody can make this simple Big Boys fresh strawberry pie dessert, so get your aprons on and let’s get baking!

Before we start making this quick Big Boys fresh strawberry pie for parties, let’s take a step back. While there’s nothing quite like a homemade strawberry pie (and this big boy strawberry pie recipe is sure to please), you need to know why it’s worth making.

Well, this family favorite Big Boys fresh strawberry pie has got a got a delicious crust and strawberries cooked to perfection. It also emulates restaurant-style pies so flawlessly that you’ll be baking Big Boys fresh strawberry pie at home whenever you can.

So if you’re looking for a delicious and refreshing summer dessert, be sure to try this fresh strawberry pie. I guarantee you’ll love it! Pairs well with our strawberry rhubarb pie recipe!

Scroll to Bottom for printable recipe card.

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

• The best Big Boys fresh strawberry pie ideas can use frozen or fresh strawberries – the main issue is to make sure that your frozen strawberries are completely thawed before use
• You can use just about any crust for this easy Big Boys fresh strawberry pie recipe – try an actual pastry crust, a graham cracker crust, or even a cookie crumb crust
• The finest homemade Big Boys fresh strawberry pie recipes are easy to make, even for beginner bakers
• This simple Big Boys fresh strawberry pie dessert pairs well with ice cream and other dishes
• A quick Big Boys fresh strawberry pie for parties will make you the life of any get-together
• Everyone loves this family favorite Big Boys fresh strawberry pie – trust us
• Getting into baking Big Boys fresh strawberry pie at home makes it easier to cook other pies later

Ingredient Notes & Substitutions

• Strawberries: Obviously, all the best Big Boys fresh strawberry pie ideas start here! You can get fresh or frozen varieties or, if you don’t like this popular berry, raspberries, bananas, and apples also work well with this easy Big Boys fresh strawberry pie recipe.
• Pie Crust: It’s hard to imagine homemade Big Boys fresh strawberry pie recipes without a pie crust! Homemade or store-bought are both strong, though homemade adds a personal touch. Want a healthier, simple Big Boys fresh strawberry pie dessert? Try butter crackers or granola.
• Strawberry Jelly: A quick Big Boys fresh strawberry pie for parties uses strawberry jelly to fill out the pie and create a rich flavor. However, your family favorite Big Boys fresh strawberry pie can try other jellies instead or even cut them out, depending on your taste. 
• Sugar: When you’re baking Big Boys fresh strawberry pie at home, you need some sugar to give it flavor. Yes, the berries are plenty sweet, but sugar makes them even better. Cutting back on your intake? Try stevia, monk fruit extract, or even sugar alcohols.

Getting Your Pie Ready

How to Make It

You’ll start by baking your crust however you want. The best Big Boys fresh strawberry pie ideas use homemade crusts, but if you’re a busy person, frozen ones are just as fine. They need to cool for 30 minutes before cooking the easy Big Boys fresh strawberry pie recipe.

Here comes the fun part of most homemade Big Boys fresh strawberry pie recipes: making the mix! You’ll warm sugar, cornstarch, and water in a pan and whisk briskly. You gotta start somewhere when making a simple Big Boys fresh strawberry pie dessert.

Now, you can bring everything to a boil and simmer for five minutes. While your mix for quick Big Boys fresh strawberry pie for parties thickens, you can play a quick game of solitaire or talk with the kids. They might even love watching it boil!

You’re getting close to the finish line! Add your strawberry jelly to your family favorite Big Boys fresh strawberry pie and whisk carefully. Take it off the stove, cut the strawberries in half, and add them to the pie crust. Pour in the jelly, and your masterpiece is almost done!

The best thing about baking Big Boys fresh strawberry pie at home at this point? You’re basically done! Let the pie cool in the fridge for a few hours before serving. You don’t have to add a top crust. In fact, it’s way better without one.

Tips for Success

• Try fun variations to get great results, such as making a strawberry cheesecake
• Use fresh strawberries to get the richest possible taste for your dessert
• Thicken the filling with cornstarch to add a little more density
• Sprinkle some lemon on top to give it a bit of a kick
• Pre-bake your crust before filling to avoid sogginess
• Chill in the freezer to make it even more fun to eat

Storage & Reheating

If there is any of your easy Big Boys fresh strawberry pie recipe left, wrap it tightly and store it in the refrigerator. Your simple Big Boys fresh strawberry pie dessert will last for up to three days in the refrigerator.  If storing your family favorite Big Boys fresh strawberry pie in the freezer, be sure it is wrapped tightly, and it will last for up to two months.

Serving Suggestions

• A quick Big Boys fresh strawberry pie for parties is best served with a bit of whipped cream or vanilla ice cream 
• Try pairing your best Big Boys fresh strawberry pie ideas with chocolate sauce or even fresh fruit
• After baking Big Boys fresh strawberry pie at home, you can try serving it with a traditional meal, such as delicious turkey dishes or burgers 
• Try these homemade Big Boys fresh strawberry pie recipes for Thanksgiving and Christmas – they’re the best time for some tasty pie

Notes

We used to serve this pie every Sunday at home, especially after our local Big Boys restaurant went out of business. Before it closed, our after church meals here always featured a slice of Big Boys pie. My mom figured out how to make this pie just so we could have restaurant-quality dishes at home. It still brings those memories back to me, and I know you and your family will make some of your own!

THANKS FOR PINING!

Do you love Strawberries? Check out these Strawberry Recipes

Strawberry Rhubarb Pie – My favorite summer pie dessert!

Strawberry Pound Cake – A fresh cake that has fresh strawberries and fluffy cake in every bite.

More Delicious Pie Recipes

Lemonade Pie – This Lemonade Pie makes a good one!

Lemon Meringue Pie – This impressive, citrusy dessert is one of our all-time favorites.