The Best Amish Chicken Recipe You’ll Ever Eat: Only a Few Ingredients!

There has always been something special about the recipes from the Amish, and the best Amish chicken recipe is no different. Like all the fabulous foods they make, this easy Amish chicken for beginners is fresh, savory, and not loaded down with unnecessary ingredients.

Frankly, my friends, I have always been in awe of the recipes these people make. With just clean food combined with ingredients, they make a special dish. For example, this simple Amish chicken meal features meat that literally falls off the bone from being so tender. 

When you combine tender chicken with a thick, savory gravy, you get a quick Amish chicken recipe that is seriously the best! Even better is that this family friendly Amish chicken is so simple that anyone can make it and serve it!

According to tradition, this quick Amish chicken recipe has no added hormones and uses meat that is considered free range. This means the chickens eat an all-natural diet and are not cooped up the entire growth period.

Even better, this healthy Amish chicken version includes garlic-roasted chicken thighs with gravy. There are very few homemade Amish chicken ideas any better than this dish!

So what are you waiting for? Let’s get to it!

Scroll to bottom for printable recipe card.

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

The best Amish chicken recipe dish is comforting and tasty like Instant Pot Mississippi Ranch Chicken – everyone loves it!

• It is super easy to make – no other easy Amish chicken for beginners is simpler – and people love it as much as Chicken Tempura
• Tender, juicy, and flavorful simple Amish chicken meal with a crispy skin – the skin traps all the flavors
• This quick Amish chicken recipe won’t take all day to make – enjoy time with your family 
• It’s easy to make a healthy Amish chicken version – it’s already pretty healthy
• Few people will turn it down – it’s a truly family friendly Amish chicken dish

Ingredient Notes & Substitutions

• Skin-On Chicken: Thighs make the best Amish chicken recipe, though breasts can work in a pinch. White meat typically cooks better, but dark meat is healthier. Don’t like the skin? Buy them without!
• Heavy Whipping Cream: Adding heavy whipping cream creates even more flavor for this already rich dish. Want something healthier for your easy Amish chicken for beginners? Try coconut cream or evaporated milk.
• All-Purpose Flour: All homemade Amish chicken ideas need flour to help the chicken breading stick. You can also choose almond flour, oat flour, chickpea flour, or rice flour, depending on your dietary needs, for this simple Amish chicken meal.
• Seasonings: Mix garlic powder, onion powder, paprika, salt, and pepper to taste for your simple Amish chicken meal. If you want a quick Amish chicken recipe without the traditional ingredients, try parsley or oregano for a healthy Amish chicken version.

How to Make It

This family friendly Amish chicken is so easy and fun to make that your kids will want to join in on it! Let them mix the flour and garlic powder in a bowl to keep them busy.

As they mix, hand them the paprika and onion powder. Clean the chicken as they mix to keep yourself busy while making the best Amish chicken recipe with them.

Adding onion powder

Dredge the chicken in the flour and get your kids to help! They’ll love making this easy Amish chicken for beginners because it lets them get their hands a little dirty.

While your kids washs their hands, grease a baking dish. Have them help you layer the chicken skin-side up on the pan. They’ll love taking the time to help you!

Truly creamy

Whisk your heavy cream in a bowl with your water while prepping this simple Amish chicken recipe. Make this a truly quick Amish chicken recipe by pre-heating the oven now.

Slowly drizzle the cream around the chicken. Have your kids tell you when “enough is enough” when making this family friendly Amish chicken. They’ll love being involved.

Bake for about an hour and a half to complete your healthy Amish chicken version. Why not play cards in the kitchen with the little ones to enjoy the smell of this dish as it cooks?

Tips for Success

• Keep your chicken at room temperature before cooking it to avoid issues. 
• Pat the fillets dry before cooking to help them bake better
• Use a meat thermometer to ensure the interior hits 165 degrees inside 
• Let the chicken sit for a few minutes to truly retain its juices
• Avoid opening the oven (even though it smells so good) to keep it at an even temperature

Storage & Reheating

Place your leftovers in an airtight container in the fridge for up to three days. It can also freeze for up to two months. Reheat in a baking dish at 350 degrees. An oven works best, though you can microwave this meal if you want.

Serving Suggestions

• Try a side of mashed potatoes for the best Amish chicken recipe 
• Roasted vegetables go even better with this simple Amish chicken meal
• A side salad also complements this quick Amish chicken recipe
• Serve a side of rice or pasta with gravy smothering everything for an easy Amish chicken for beginners that everyone will love
• Bring it out with some warm bread for a family friendly Amish chicken dish – these and other homemade Amish chicken ideas are super clever
• Make a healthy Amish chicken version with green beans and broccoli topping it

Notes

I’m not kidding when I said that kids love making this meal! Mine get really hands-on and dig right into it. There’s something about mixing together the flour that they really enjoy. Honestly, I think kids just like getting dirty. 

Use this simple meal to teach them a little about cooking. It’s also a fun way to touch on Amish culture, as many children don’t know a thing about it. Educational and tasty? That’s a big win in my book!

THANKS FOR PINING!!

More Amish Recipes

Onion Fritters – This Amish Onion Fritters Recipe will leave you satisfied and impressed by the incredible flavor.

Sweet Bread – With just a few simple steps and minimal time spent in the kitchen, you’ll be on your way to creating an irresistibly yummy treat that will have everyone asking for seconds!

Homemade Amish Caramels – Simple ingredients, easy to make, and good to eat.